Yahya Abdul-Mateen II says Wonder Man’s Simon Williams feels personal to audiences
The actor behind Black Manta and Watchmen explains why Marvel’s Simon resonates, and what that means for casting bets.

US actor Yahya Abdul-Mateen II, known for DC’s Black Manta in the Aquaman films and HBO’s Watchmen, reportedly said “people see so much of themselves in (protagonist) Simon (Williams)” in Marvel’s Wonder Man. For decision-makers watching blockbuster IP, the takeaway is how character relatability can drive audience connection and reduce risk in franchise strategy.
DUBAI: US actor Yahya Abdul-Mateen II is reportedly saying something Marvel casting teams love to hear, and studios gamble on: audiences project themselves onto the protagonist. He specifically said “people see so much of themselves in (protagonist) Simon (Williams),” the role he plays in Marvel’s Wonder Man. In other words, Abdul-Mateen II’s pitch for the character is not just about spectacle. It is about identification.
That matters because Abdul-Mateen II is not a blank slate. Comic book fans already know him from DC’s Aquaman movies as Black Manta, and from HBO’s Watchmen where he had a breakout role before he was cast in Wonder Man in 2022. So when he connects Simon Williams to the feeling of “seeing yourself” in him, he is also effectively telling the market why his career path makes sense for this moment: he brings existing genre credibility and a track record of performing within comic-book universes that demand emotional hooks.
To understand why this is strategically interesting, you have to look at how franchise entertainment works as a business. Marvel is built on audience memory. Viewers arrive with expectations formed by prior storylines, characters, and performances, and they decide fast whether a new offering earns their attention. That is why “relatability” is not fluff in Hollywood terms. It is a lever that can influence everything downstream, from how trailers perform to whether the early audience actually returns.
Abdul-Mateen II’s comment is also a reminder that Marvel is running more than one play at once. On the surface, Wonder Man is an IP product. Underneath, it is also a risk management exercise. Casting decisions in large universes try to balance recognition with freshness. Abdul-Mateen II’s background provides recognition. His Watchmen breakout role suggests range beyond costume roles. His Black Manta turn anchors him in comic-book theatrics that are familiar to Marvel’s core demo.
There is another layer here that executives in media and broader corporate strategy will care about: audience identification tends to change how “brand safety” is defined. Media companies operate in an environment where public reception can be volatile, and where platforms and partners increasingly look for narratives that travel well across demographics and geographies. A protagonist framed as someone viewers can see themselves in can lower the odds of a disconnected audience response, especially when the story needs to hold attention beyond the first big action beat.
Now connect that to the timing. Abdul-Mateen II was cast in Wonder Man in 2022. That means the company has had at least a planning window to shape positioning, marketing angles, and audience targeting around the actor and the character. When an actor later articulates why the character resonates, it can become a reinforcement loop. Marketing teams can align on a simple message: Simon Williams is not just a figure in a Marvel universe. He is a conduit for viewers’ emotions. That kind of messaging can matter for decision-makers trying to coordinate creative, PR, and commercial expectations without drifting into generic hype.
There is also a board-level implication hiding in plain sight. When studios pick actors with prior success in adjacent universes, the goal is often to borrow trust. Comic book fans already “know the face.” That can reduce friction when the new project asks viewers to invest time and attention. But studios still need more than familiarity. They need an angle that can keep the audience engaged through the middle of the story, not only the opening weekend.
Abdul-Mateen II’s line about people seeing themselves in Simon Williams speaks directly to that middle. If viewers emotionally map the protagonist onto their own experiences, the project can gain durability. That is how executives think about franchise longevity: not just opening numbers, but whether the audience finds a reason to keep following.
For peers considering similar casting bets, the strategic stakes are clear. The entertainment market is crowded, and the competition for attention is relentless. A lead performance that gives the character an identity viewers can recognize and attach to can serve as a hedge against the ever-present risk of mismatch between IP and audience mood. Abdul-Mateen II is effectively arguing that Simon Williams offers that bridge, which is exactly what big-universe projects need to earn trust one scene at a time.
This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.
Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.
Register to UnlockAlways free for Executives Club members. Join the Club
More in Entertainment

Christopher Nolan’s “The Odyssey” posts his biggest Tuesday haul, surpassing “The Dark Knight’s” record
The film’s Tuesday breakout reframes Nolan’s box-office ceiling and forces competitors to rethink timing, budgets, and release strategy.

Kacey Musgraves cancels Aug. 20, 29, Sept. 2 Middle of Nowhere shows
Ticketmaster emails are telling fans refunds are coming, while the tour still starts Aug. 21 in Chicago.

Billie Joe Armstrong launches Epiphone Les Paul Junior and Marshall 1959BJA signature gear
Two limited releases turn decades of Green Day’s tone into branded hardware, including Marshall’s first artist amp in 14 years.

