Skip to content
LIVE
The Executives BriefThe Executives Brief

Google to schools: keep Gemini or lose Search. NYC, LA, Chicago weigh exit

Three of the largest US school districts are shopping for alternatives after Google's education chief confirmed Search and Gemini can no longer be switched off separately.

ByAbdullah Al-OtaibiBusiness Desk, The Executives Brief
·3 min read
Google to schools: keep Gemini or lose Search. NYC, LA, Chicago weigh exit
Executive summary

Google's vice president of education, Chris Phillips, told The New York Times that "Search and AI are deeply integrated," meaning schools that disable Gemini-powered features will lose Search entirely starting next year. New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago are now considering alternatives, turning a product toggle into a national fight over AI in public schools.

The ultimatum is now explicit. Chris Phillips, Google's vice president of education, told The New York Times that "Search and AI are deeply integrated," and that schools which turn off Google's AI features "will not have access to Search." Starting next year, the separate off switch disappears: districts that want Gemini-powered features disabled will have to give up Search as well. The Verge reports that New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago, three of the nation's largest school systems, are now considering Google alternatives.

The political reaction arrived fast. Many elected officials, including New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Senator Bernie Sanders, responded harshly to the change, according to the report. That is a notable escalation for what used to be a quiet procurement decision. School technology contracts rarely make national news. This one did, because it touches two live nerves at once: parents' unease about AI in classrooms, and a growing suspicion that the largest technology companies can set the terms of public education unilaterally.

To understand why the bundling matters, look at how Google got into schools in the first place. Chromebooks and Workspace for Education became the default stack in a huge share of American classrooms, typically on free or heavily discounted terms. The trade was straightforward: districts got cheap hardware and software, and Google got a generation of users trained on its products. For years, the ability to switch off specific features was the safety valve that let cautious districts say yes. Administrators could adopt the platform while telling parents that certain capabilities were disabled. Remove the valve and the sales pitch changes.

That valve mattered more than ever once generative AI arrived. Over the past two years, districts have written AI policies, negotiated data processing agreements, and fielded questions from parents about what student data trains which model. Federal law sets the floor: FERPA governs education records, and COPPA restricts data collection from children under 13. State legislatures have layered on their own disclosure and consent rules. A district's AI policy is only as strong as its ability to enforce it inside the products students actually use. If the toggle is gone, the policy document and the product no longer match, and the district's general counsel inherits the gap.

There is also a commercial logic worth naming. Education has long been a funnel business: free at the front, paid at the back, with students and teachers as the distribution channel. Bundling Gemini into Search means AI adoption happens by default rather than by choice, which is efficient for Google and uncomfortable for everyone who wanted a say. Expect the word "tying" to enter the conversation. Whether or not any regulator acts, the optics of conditioning one product on acceptance of another are exactly the kind of thing antitrust watchers, state attorneys general, and school boards tend to notice.

Then there is the switching math, which is brutal. Leaving a platform means replacing devices, identity and email systems, storage, classroom tools, and years of teacher training, usually mid-contract and mid-budget-cycle. That is why "considering alternatives" is not the same as leaving. But the threat is credible precisely because of who is making it. New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago are large enough to command vendor attention, and their procurement teams are sophisticated enough to run a real evaluation. If even one of them moves, it hands every smaller district in the country a template.

What to watch from here. First, whether Google offers a carve-out for districts that want Search without Gemini, which would defuse the fight without changing the underlying integration. Second, whether lawmakers escalate from criticism to legislation, given that two prominent elected officials have already weighed in. Third, whether the districts actually sign elsewhere or use the threat as leverage in renewal talks. The clock is short: the change takes effect next year, and school technology decisions are typically locked in months before students show up.

The broader lesson travels well beyond K-12. As AI features get folded into core infrastructure, the question of what customers can opt out of stops being a settings-menu detail and becomes a contract term, a compliance question, and eventually a political one. Google just showed the industry how quickly that transition happens. Every executive selling software with AI baked in should assume their own toggle question is coming, and that the answer will be read aloud at a school board meeting, a shareholder meeting, or a hearing.

Executive ActionsLocked

This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.

Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.

Register to Unlock

Always free for Executives Club members. Join the Club

More in Politics