Insurers Raked In $5B on War Claims. The Government Calls It Fraud-Prone.
A ProPublica investigation finds insurers collected nearly $5B from a program for civilian war contractors, while Labor's own memo warns the system is ripe for fraud.

A ProPublica investigation found U.S. taxpayers paid nearly $5 billion to insurers through the Defense Base Act, with AIG, CNA, Starr and Allied World collecting the most, while a Labor Department memo obtained by ProPublica called the program "ripe for potential fraud or, at the very least, gamesmanship for profit." For boards and operators, the findings expose a low-visibility federal reimbursement channel where weak controls, outdated systems and a 2018 PTSD documentation change have turned war-zone workers' compensation into a profit center.
Over the past decade, American taxpayers have paid nearly $5 billion to insurance companies through an obscure federal program meant to cover civilians harmed in U.S. wars. The Defense Base Act workers' compensation system was supposed to be a safety net for employees of government contractors injured or killed in Iraq and Afghanistan. Instead, a ProPublica investigation found, a handful of insurers became its biggest beneficiaries. Four large companies have benefited most since 2014: AIG more than $1 billion, CNA Financial more than $740 million, Starr insurance more than $730 million, and Allied World more than $350 million, according to a ProPublica analysis of Labor Department records. None of the companies has been accused of wrongdoing.
The government itself has described the program as "ripe for potential fraud or, at the very least, gamesmanship for profit," according to an internal memo ProPublica obtained. Nobody knows the true amount of misspent money. The official who oversaw the program under the Biden administration estimated that between $100 million and $150 million is wasted annually. The memo, a 25-page internal review ordered by Chris Godfrey after Biden appointed him to oversee the program in 2021, is an indictment of the agency's incompetence and apathy, ProPublica reported. The Labor Department declined to release it.
How the system works matters. In recent conflicts, the U.S. supplemented its armed forces with hundreds of thousands of workers from around the world to provide security, maintain weapons systems, and supply troops with food, housing, and transportation. Military officials say it would be all but impossible for America to go to war without them. Contractors buy private insurance that the government pays for as part of the bid. When an employee is injured, insurers cover medical treatments and lost wages. If a worker dies, they pay benefits to survivors. But if injury or death results from hostilities, rather than an ordinary workplace accident like slipping on a wet floor, the U.S. government reimburses the insurer for the claim and adds a handling fee.
That exception has become an exploit. Some insurers settle dubious claims quickly, with little or no investigation, assured of government reimbursement, according to the Labor Department's internal memo. It is a churn strategy: cycle cases fast, get paid fast. Others take the opposite tack. Insurers fight workers in court for years, racking up expenses. If they decide to settle, they can turn to the Labor Department and report that the injury they sought to deny is in fact authentic. They can then seek reimbursement by asserting the employee suffered an injury related to hostilities, according to department records. Put bluntly: insurers change their stories and get paid when they do it.
The agency also created the opportunity for abuse, ProPublica found. After lobbying by industry executives, officials loosened the rules for documenting PTSD cases in 2018. The change spurred a wave of questionable claims by workers and suspect payments to insurers, according to industry insiders. Reimbursements to insurance companies more than tripled after the decision, reaching nearly $1 billion through September 2026. Meanwhile, the Labor Department has proven incapable of policing the program. No standards exist to determine whether an insurer has asked for excessive or unreasonable payments. The department's computer system is so dysfunctional it can't issue fines. Until recently, federal examiners relied on decades-old CD-ROM technology to process thousands of reimbursement requests. An effort to hire experts to investigate insurance industry books failed.
Former Labor officials admit the agency does not possess the expertise or employees to oversee the money flowing to insurers. "You can't look under the covers. You just had to pay," one former senior manager said. In at least one case, the federal government reimbursed an insurance company for so-called medical expenses that had nothing to do with treating a wounded worker. The insurer received more than $24,000 for "medical" fees that included the cost of hand-delivering records to the insurer's hired doctor and deposing one of its paid experts. The miscategorization, approved by the Labor Department, allowed the insurer to also collect handling fees on those expenses, adding another $25,000 it was not entitled to receive, according to department regulations.
This is not a new warning. The Labor Department has been on notice about failures in the Defense Base Act program for years. A 2009 ProPublica investigation prompted congressional hearings. The Pentagon and other agencies documented profiteering by the insurance industry. A senior official at the time acknowledged "systemic problems." The agency worked with Congress and the White House on initiatives to fix the system. The central idea: have the federal government, rather than insurance companies, pay for benefits for injured workers, just as it did for its own employees. In the industry, this is called self-insurance, and it is generally cheaper than using private insurers. Legislation introduced by Democrats in 2013 died in committee. A similar initiative pushed by President Barack Obama's administration was never adopted by Congress. With the wars drawing to a close, the urgency to fix the system disappeared. The problems did not.
As the wars continued through Democratic and Republican administrations, workers kept filing claims. Cases piled up. Court battles began to take years to resolve. Workers suffered without care. Insurers collected more and more reimbursements for those injured in battle. By the time Biden appointed Godfrey in 2021, the program had turned into a classic Washington phenomenon: an out-of-sight, out-of-mind bureaucracy, impervious to reform and susceptible to corruption. The memo details a system vulnerable to abuse: "The process still lacks safeguards in some areas." "Questionable medical evidence is often overlooked." "Minimal investigation by insurers during the course of... litigation." For executives and boards, the lesson is not just about war claims. It is about what happens when a reimbursement channel has weak controls, misaligned incentives, and no real enforcement. The hidden costs of America's wars on terror are being reported here for the first time. They are also a warning about any program where the government pays the bill and private companies decide what to charge.
This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.
Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.
Register to UnlockAlways free for Executives Club members. Join the Club
More in Business
S&P 500 Enters Correction, Down 10% From Its High on AI Worries
The index's slide past the 10 percent line is a symbolic verdict on investor mood, and the AI trade that powered the rally is now the thing testing it.
Dow and S&P 500 enter correction as Nasdaq logs worst week since 2020
All 11 S&P 500 sectors fell more than 1% in the same week for the first time since April 2025, a breadth signal that matters more than any single index level.
Chip stocks lose $2.3 trillion in a week, worst run in 25 years
A $2.3 trillion weekly wipeout in semiconductors is forcing every board with an AI story to ask whether it owns a thesis or just a crowded trade.



