Meta's Muse is canceling forgotten subscriptions. No law says sellers must allow it
AI agents are clawing back thousands in charges users forgot they were paying, and with no federal or state rule forcing sellers to honor an agent's cancellation, subscription businesses must choose between protected revenue and easier sign-ups.
Meta's Muse, an AI agent released in September, is finding and canceling subscriptions users forgot they were paying, including roughly $1,200 a year for Nashville's Scott Burka and $9,000 in annual charges for Cisco president Jeetu Patel. No federal or state law says a seller must accept a cancellation an agent sends on a customer's behalf, leaving subscription businesses to weigh the forgotten revenue they already collect against the sign-ups that frictionless canceling attracts.
Scott Burka had been paying for his kids' iPad subscriptions and chess accounts without noticing until Muse, the AI agent Meta released in September to handle digital chores, went looking. Burka told the agent he was not using any of them, and it helped him cancel approximately $100 worth of expenses a month, he told NPR. That is about $1,200 a year he had been spending completely under the radar, or nearly two-thirds of what the average American spent on their entire subscription bill last year, according to Mastercard and FT Strategies. The detail that should worry every subscription seller: lawyers at Venable, a firm that advises subscription companies on cancellation rules, wrote last week that no federal or state law says whether a company has to accept a cancellation request an AI agent sends on behalf of a customer.
Burka is not an outlier. Jeetu Patel, Cisco's president and chief product officer, told Business Insider last month that a personal AI agent, on its first pass through his inbox, found he was paying $9,000 a year in subscriptions. Patel asked it for a table showing what each one cost and how long he had held it, chose two he did not need, and told the agent to drop them. It canceled both and forwarded him the confirmations. "I'm like, OK, that was kind of creepy how easy it was to do that," Patel said. "And then it saved me 1,000, 1,200 bucks a year just over there." The agent costs him $20 a month, or $240 a year, so those two cancellations alone cover it four to five times over.
The economics behind those small wins are enormous in aggregate. Stanford economists Liran Einav, Ben Klopack and Neale Mahoney estimated in a 2025 paper in the American Economic Review that sellers take in roughly twice as much money, on average, as they would if customers never put off canceling. Subscribers rarely get pushed to decide: one of the few forced moments comes when a bank replaces a card, which stops every subscription billed to the old one unless the subscriber steps in. Einav, Klopack and Mahoney found many more people cancel in those months. Mahoney, who directs the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, told CNBC that people forced to make that choice "are about four times more likely to cancel." Muse puts that decision in front of users on every charge it finds, not only when a new card arrives in the mail. More than one in 10 U.S. subscribers told Mastercard they are still billed for something they do not use. Bryan T. Cafferelli, Connecticut's consumer protection commissioner, said in July that "if it's difficult to cancel - requiring a phone call or a deep dive internet search - sometimes it's easier to just give up and continue paying for a subscription you don't need or want."
Sellers of digital services stand to lose the most once agents start turning up forgotten charges. Mahoney points out that people rarely forget they are paying for pet food, because a new bag shows up on the doorstep every month. A credit-monitoring service sends nothing to the door, and it can keep billing customers long after they have forgotten it. The quiet monthly bill from a digital service is exactly the kind of charge an agent turns up. One Silicon Valley correspondent for Maeil Business Newspaper, a South Korean daily, wrote in September about paying Otter, an AI service that writes up meeting notes, $99 a year for several years. In 2025 the correspondent decided to cancel before the next renewal date, then forgot, and Otter charged another $99 in June. Muse flagged that charge once the correspondent linked a Bank of America account, and one request to cancel took care of everything else, without the correspondent ever visiting Otter's site or hunting for a cancel button.
Two months in, sellers are not yet bleeding. Antenna, a firm that tracks U.S. streaming subscriptions, reported Nov. 3 that fewer people canceled the big paid streaming services in September, the month Meta began rolling out Muse. Asked on The New York Times Company's quarterly call with investors this month whether personal AI agents were leading subscribers to cancel, CEO and president Meredith Kopit Levien said, "So far, we're not seeing an impact," adding that the company is "actively watching how the technology and consumer behavior are going to evolve here." The Times still added more digital subscribers than it lost from July through September.
Blocking is the obvious defense, and it is already happening somewhere. Amazon barred Muse from buying anything on its site, saying the agent broke Amazon's terms of service. A subscription seller could try to block Muse from canceling the same way, and no law clearly says it cannot. Kopit Levien told analysts on the same call that the Times has "the ability to permit, to restrict, or to block specific tools." The trade-off is real. Jordan Mackler, co-founder and CEO of ScribeUp, which builds subscription-management tools into banking apps, said, "If consumers trust that they can easily see, manage, and cancel recurring charges, our data shows they are likely to expand their overall recurring spend and are more willing to try new services in the first place." A seller that blocks agents protects the forgotten charges it already collects but gives up some of the sign-ups that easy canceling brings in.
No federal rule settles the question. In 2025, a federal appeals court threw out the Federal Trade Commission's 2024 rule, which would have required sellers to offer a simple way to cancel and stop every recurring charge right away. In February, the FTC restored its 1973 rule, which covers only merchandise plans that mail members a notice of each upcoming shipment. When the FTC asked the public in March whether to bring back parts of the 2024 rule, lawyers at the firm Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner wrote in Legal 500 that the agency had taken only the first step of a process that takes years. In the meantime, the Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act still makes online sellers give customers a "simple" way to end billing, but it never says what simple means, let alone whether a cancellation sent by an agent counts. California requires businesses that let customers sign up online to let them cancel at any time, covering subscriptions signed, changed or extended since July 1, 2025, and Connecticut's law, updated this July, makes sellers with a website offer an online cancel option or a cancellation email address.
That leaves both sides roughly where they started, at least for now: Muse users keep what they save, and sellers like the Times can still decide whether to let the agents in at all. The pressure point is not this quarter's churn number. It is whether a competitor decides that frictionless canceling is a customer acquisition weapon, and the forgotten revenue propping up a subscription P&L becomes a liability that agents can unwind one charge at a time.
This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.
Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.
Register to UnlockAlways free for Executives Club members. Join the Club
More in Business
S&P 500 Enters Correction, Down 10% From Its High on AI Worries
The index's slide past the 10 percent line is a symbolic verdict on investor mood, and the AI trade that powered the rally is now the thing testing it.
Dow and S&P 500 enter correction as Nasdaq logs worst week since 2020
All 11 S&P 500 sectors fell more than 1% in the same week for the first time since April 2025, a breadth signal that matters more than any single index level.
Chip stocks lose $2.3 trillion in a week, worst run in 25 years
A $2.3 trillion weekly wipeout in semiconductors is forcing every board with an AI story to ask whether it owns a thesis or just a crowded trade.



