Skip to content
LIVE
The Executives BriefThe Executives Brief

PwC: pitch AI to unlock ERP budgets. Kingfisher skipped the upgrade anyway

PwC's Jennifer Colapietro says a 'clean core' makes AI agents easier to deploy, and that is the business case IT leaders should take to the board; Kingfisher took the other route, keeping ECC on Rimini Street support with Databricks and Google.

ByOmar Al-BalawiTechnology Correspondent, The Executives Brief
·4 min read
PwC: pitch AI to unlock ERP budgets. Kingfisher skipped the upgrade anyway
Executive summary

PwC digital core modernization leader Jennifer Colapietro says IT leaders should sell ERP migrations as the fastest route to AI value rather than as incremental process improvement, because a 'clean core' makes AI agents easier to deploy. The counterexample is Kingfisher, which refused SAP's upgrade push, kept its ECC system on Rimini Street support, and built its AI strategy on Databricks and Google instead.

PwC has a message for IT leaders who cannot get their ERP migration funded: stop selling it as better plumbing. Sell it as the thing that makes AI work. Jennifer Colapietro, who leads PwC's digital core modernization platform practice, told The Register that AI value has moved from a nice-to-have slide to a load-bearing beam in the business case. "You're seeing it a lot more as part of the rationale for the business case for why they should upgrade, answering the question: 'Why now? What should we prioritize?'" she said. "Certainly, AI and getting the value of AI, a key business case justification for that." The urgency is real. A survey of SAP users last year found 95 percent said building a positive case for migration required substantial effort or was genuinely challenging. That is a brutal hit rate for a project that can run for years and touch every function in the company.

The PwC argument rests on a phrase that has become shorthand in enterprise software: the "clean core." That means modern enterprise applications with fewer customizations baked into the underlying system. The fewer bespoke patches welded onto the foundation, the easier it is to bolt on AI agents that read data, trigger workflows, and take over work humans used to do. Both of the giants pushing this narrative are PwC partners. SAP wants customers on S/4HANA, preferably in the cloud. Oracle wants them on Fusion Cloud Applications. Moving off SAP ECC or Oracle E-Business Suite is not a software upgrade in any normal sense; it is a root-and-branch rebuild of technology and business processes. Thousands of organizations are still running those aging, heavily customized systems, which is exactly why the sales pitch has been so hard to land.

Then comes the budget math. Colapietro's framing is that ERP money and AI money are no longer separate pots. "Folks have budgets for ERP, but now [funding for transformation is] being split because they also have budgets for AI," she said. "But there's synergies across them. If you look at moving to a clean digital core ERP, that will help them to realize the AI value faster... be able to turn on AI and be able to start to automate a lot of the processes and implement the agents. That helps to build the business case." In plain English: the CFO already has an AI line item. PwC's advice is to attach the ERP migration to it rather than fight for a standalone check.

The vendors are supplying the ammunition. SAP recently introduced Joule 2.0, and Oracle has announced Fusion Claw. Both promise customers they can build AI agents that automate business processes and absorb work previously done by people. Colapietro's claim is that this works far better on a modern platform than on a legacy one. "It is more challenging to apply AI to the older systems," she said. "We focus on the importance of a clean digital core as the foundation for getting the value and effectiveness out of AI and scaling AI responsibly. I think that's given."

Not everyone is buying it. Kingfisher, the European home improvement retailer behind the UK's B&Q, turned down SAP's overtures to upgrade its ECC system despite the deadlines closing in. Mainstream maintenance for supported ECC 6.0 versions ends in December 2027. Optional extended maintenance runs through 2030, but at a premium of two percentage points on the existing maintenance base. Kingfisher instead went to third-party support provider Rimini Street and built its AI strategy around the ERP it already owns, using a combination of technology from Databricks and Google. That is the counterargument in one company: the AI capability did not require a new core, it required new tools pointed at the old one.

That matters because the deadline is the real sales weapon here, not the AI story. Every year a CIO delays, the deadline math gets worse and the eventual rebuild gets bigger. PwC's pitch gives IT leaders a way to convert a defensive, cost-avoidance conversation into an offensive one about growth and automation. Kingfisher's route gives them a way to defer the whole thing and spend the difference on AI tooling instead. Both are now legitimate board-level options, which is precisely what makes this moment uncomfortable for SAP and Oracle.

For peers in the same seat, the practical question is not "AI or ERP." It is which AI use cases actually need a clean core and which ones can run on top of what you already have. Agents that touch finance close, supply chain planning, or master data usually want clean, standardized data underneath them. Agents pointed at a narrow workflow, a document queue, or a customer service inbox often do not. The CIO who can draw that line precisely, and price both paths honestly, walks into the board meeting with something better than a vendor slide: a decision.

Executive ActionsLocked

This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.

Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.

Register to Unlock

Always free for Executives Club members. Join the Club

More in Technology