Skip to content
LIVE
The Executives BriefThe Executives Brief

Black holes are giving physicists reasons to doubt space-time is fundamental

A 1974 paradox, a 1997 math trick and a growing pile of black hole clues are pushing researchers to call space-time an output rather than a stage, and the quantum computers and precision lasers behind the work are industry hardware too.

ByHessa Al-FalehBusiness Desk, The Executives Brief
·4 min read
Black holes are giving physicists reasons to doubt space-time is fundamental
Executive summary

Jeff Forshaw of the University of Manchester and Latham Boyle of the University of Edinburgh are among a growing group of physicists arguing that space-time, treated as fundamental for more than 100 years, may instead emerge from something deeper, with black hole thermodynamics and the holographic principle as the strongest clues. For decision-makers, the significance is that the unresolved conflict between general relativity and quantum mechanics now runs through instruments and talent pools that commercial quantum computing and precision measurement also depend on.

The evidence is not coming from a particle collider. It is coming from the edge of a black hole. For more than 100 years, physics has been built on one foundational assumption: that space-time, the four-dimensional fabric of the universe, is fundamental. A growing number of physicists are now treating that assumption as the thing to doubt. "You can build space from a theory without space," Jeff Forshaw, a professor of particle physics at the University of Manchester in the U.K., told Live Science. Read that again: the arena everything happens in may be a product, not a stage. If the emerging case holds, the bedrock of reality is a large-scale approximation of something stranger.

The push comes from a stalemate physics has lived with for decades. Einstein's general theory of relativity says matter and energy bend space-time, and we experience that curvature as gravity. Quantum mechanics describes atoms and subatomic particles with extraordinary success, but it still has no adequate description of the force of gravity. "They seem not to fit together into a single, consistent framework that we know to be correct," Latham Boyle, a theoretical physicist at the University of Edinburgh in the U.K., told Live Science. One or both theories may simply be incomplete. The more interesting possibility, and the increasingly popular one, is that both are perched on an untested assumption: space-time itself. Neither explains why the universe appears to have three dimensions of space and one of time, or where space-time comes from.

In Einstein's model, space-time behaves a little like water looked before anyone knew about molecules: smooth and continuous, able to bend and ripple. Water only appears that way because we cannot see its component bits. "It seems smooth but only because we can't view it under a fine enough microscope," Boyle said. That is the emergent hypothesis, and no one has found direct evidence for space-time's microscopic ingredients. The search for indirect clues therefore runs through the places where existing theories snap. At the heart of a black hole, general relativity breaks down by predicting space-time curving infinitely, while quantum physics gives black hole boundaries baffling properties.

Black holes also leave fingerprints of a hidden microstructure. The first is thermodynamics, the laws governing heat, temperature and entropy. Entropy is usually described as disorder, but physicists use it to count how many hidden microscopic arrangements can produce the same large-scale behavior. A glass of water has one temperature and one pressure even though its molecules could be arranged and moving in an enormous number of ways. More possible arrangements means more entropy. If Einstein's equations are thermodynamic in nature, their entropy may come from hidden microscopic states of space-time. "General relativity is thermodynamics," Forshaw said. "Einstein's equations are a statement of thermodynamics. They're a statistically emergent feature of an underlying theory."

In the 1970s, Jacob Bekenstein and Stephen Hawking showed that black holes have entropy and a physical temperature. That raised the obvious follow-up: which microscopic ingredients account for those properties? Boyle points to something stranger still. Einstein's equations appear to reproduce the relationships needed for a black hole to have a temperature, even though the theory connects the shape of space-time only to the matter it contains. "Einstein's equation, which we thought was just a classical equation, nothing to do with quantum mechanics, seems to secretly know - or at some level to have known - about this finite entropy associated with the black hole," he said.

The second clue is the black hole information paradox. Quantum mechanics says physical information can never be destroyed. But if black holes emit radiation, as Hawking proposed in 1974, they should slowly evaporate. Hawking radiation is thermal: it depends solely on mass, electric charge and angular momentum, and carries no obvious record of what originally fell in. If the black hole eventually disappears, the information it swallowed seems to vanish with it. Then comes the arithmetic that reshaped the field. A black hole's entropy scales not with the three-dimensional volume it encloses but with the two-dimensional area of its event horizon, the point beyond which nothing, not even light, can escape. So all the information within a region might somehow be stored on its boundary. That became the holographic principle, named after a hologram, in which a 3D image is encoded on a 2D surface.

In 1997, theoretical physicist Juan Maldacena made the idea mathematically precise. He showed that a higher-dimensional theory containing gravity could be mapped onto a lower-dimensional quantum theory without it. The two descriptions appeared interchangeable, equally valid views of reality. Some researchers now go further: the lower-dimensional quantum theory may be the fundamental description, and the higher-dimensional space-time we seem to inhabit is what emerges when its information is decoded. "You should think of the lower-dimensional thing as being what's most real," said Mark Van Raamsdonk, a professor of physics at the University of British Columbia.

That is the state of play: a serious, mathematically productive research program with no direct evidence yet for space-time's microscopic bits. The honest read for operators and investors is not a product roadmap. It is that the instruments generating these clues, black holes, quantum computers and ultraprecise lasers, overlap heavily with hardware the commercial world is already scaling. Tools built for computation and measurement are now the tools probing the foundation of physics, which means progress is partly bound to precision and capability, not just to theory. Nobody knows the answer. But the question has moved from philosophy seminar to calculation, and that calculation is paid for in talent, instruments and patience.

Executive ActionsLocked

This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.

Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.

Register to Unlock

Always free for Executives Club members. Join the Club

More in Science