Skip to content
LIVE
The Executives BriefThe Executives Brief

David Ellison Torches the Tom Cruise Myth Behind Hollywood's Tax Credit

Paramount's CEO told the DealBook summit the proposed federal film incentive is a below-the-line jobs program, not a subsidy for movie stars, and he got testy defending it.

ByMaha Al-JuhaniEntertainment Correspondent, The Executives Brief
·3 min read
David Ellison Torches the Tom Cruise Myth Behind Hollywood's Tax Credit
Executive summary

David Ellison, the Paramount chief executive, used the New York Times DealBook summit to reject the idea that a proposed federal film and television tax credit is a giveaway to stars like Tom Cruise, framing it instead as a rescue for below-the-line crew jobs. For studio chiefs, state governments, and anyone with production exposure, the fight over that framing will decide whether a federal incentive ever becomes law.

David Ellison took the stage at the New York Times DealBook summit, covered a lot of ground, and cleared a few landmines. Then he reached the federal film and television tax credit, and the temperature changed. The Paramount chief executive got testy, and his core argument was a direct shot at the way the incentive gets sold to the public: it is not a gift to Tom Cruise. It is a rescue mission for below-the-line jobs. "When you look at who this incentive helps, the misnomer out there is you're giving..." Ellison said, according to Deadline's account, before making the case that the money lands with the crew rather than the marquee.

That single sentence is the whole ballgame. A federal production incentive lives or dies on how voters and lawmakers picture the recipient. Picture a movie star and the proposal looks like corporate welfare for the wealthy. Picture a grip, a set carpenter, a driver, a hair and makeup artist, and it looks like a jobs bill. Ellison is not arguing about the size of the credit. He is arguing about the story attached to it, because the story is what survives a floor vote.

So what is below the line? It is everything that happens after the script and before the premiere. Electricians, riggers, camera operators, sound technicians, costume makers, set painters, location scouts, caterers, truck drivers, and the small businesses that rent them equipment. These are the roles that vanish first when production leaves a region and return last when it comes back. They are also, historically, the most unionized and most geographically spread part of the business, which is why they carry political weight far beyond Hollywood's zip codes. A star can shoot on a soundstage anywhere. A crew is anchored to a place.

The backdrop matters here. Film and television production has been through a brutal stretch: the 2023 strikes halted work for months, and the streaming era's spending correction kept the pipeline thinner than the industry was built for. In that vacuum, states have fought hard for what remains. California, Georgia, Louisiana, New York, and others have long used their own credits to pull shoots across their borders, and the competition has only sharpened as volume fell. A federal credit would sit on top of that patchwork, which is exactly why the design details, who qualifies, what counts as a qualified spend, whether it is refundable, matter as much as the headline number.

There is an obvious tension in a studio chief making this pitch. Ellison runs a major studio, and a tax credit lowers his cost base. That is the attack line any opponent will use, and it is why the below-the-line framing is not just messaging, it is armor. If the credit is a jobs program, then the CEO asking for it is a jobs advocate. If it is a studio subsidy, he is a guy asking taxpayers to underwrite his slate. Same policy, two completely different political outcomes.

The Tom Cruise reference is doing real work too. He is the most recognizable face in the business, the star most associated with doing his own stunts and carrying a franchise on his shoulders. He is also the perfect foil for critics who want to argue that incentives enrich people who do not need enriching. Ellison's counter is that the misnomer is the entire problem: the public is picturing the wrong person. Whether that reframe lands is a communications question as much as a policy one, and it is the kind of question that decides whether an incentive gets extended, expanded, or quietly left to expire.

For peers in the same seat, the lesson is structural. Any leader asking for public money should assume the most telegenic beneficiary will become the face of the program, whether or not that is accurate. The fix is to name the actual beneficiaries early, in plain language, and to do it before opponents name them for you. Ellison did that on a DealBook stage, in front of an audience that will repeat it. The next move belongs to lawmakers, who will decide whether a federal credit is a jobs program, a studio subsidy, or nothing at all. Watch the framing, not just the number.

Executive ActionsLocked

This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.

Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.

Register to Unlock

Always free for Executives Club members. Join the Club

More in Entertainment