Emilija Morrison escaped Neet life. Her new job is just as precarious
A Glasgow graduate with an NCTJ diploma welcomes the government's youth jobs plans, but warns that a paycheque without security is not an exit from Neet life.
University of Glasgow graduate and NCTJ-trained writer Emilija Morrison, who spent part of her life as a Neet, argues in the Guardian that the government's plans to help young people not in education, work or training are welcome but must deliver long-term security rather than short-term placements. For employers and policymakers, her account is a warning that employment headcount can mask precarity, and that retention, not placement, is the number that will decide whether youth labour policy actually works.
Emilija Morrison did not grow up dreaming of the jobcentre. The University of Glasgow graduate, who holds a Gold Standard NCTJ Diploma in journalism, spent part of her life as a Neet, the policy label for young people not in education, employment or training, and she says plainly that she hated it. She has since found a job. Her argument, published in the Guardian, is that the job has not delivered what the label promised: life is, in her framing, just as precarious as before. That distance between holding a job and holding security is the entire point of her piece, and it is the part policymakers tend to skip.
Morrison welcomes the government's plans to help young people who are not in education, work or training. Then she attaches a condition that rarely makes it into a policy document: she dearly hopes those plans offer long-term security. Read that twice, because it is the sharpest line in the column. She is not asking for a larger benefit cheque, and she is not asking for sympathy. She is asking whether the state's answer to youth unemployment will create durable work, or simply shift people from one form of instability into another that is harder to see on a chart.
Her story starts at 10, in the classroom ritual where every child is asked what they want to be. Imagine the answer, she writes: "I want to be unemployed. After I graduate from university, I want to go to the jobcentre in my home town and collect my benefits every month." No child says that. Yet Morrison argues it is the reality for many young people, whose dreams of becoming a teacher, a doctor or an engineer are "thwarted not by the limits of their abilities, but the reality of the economy." That single sentence moves the blame. This is not a story about ambition deficits. It is a story about a labour market that does not absorb the people it trains.
Neet is one of those acronyms that conceals more than it explains. For context, the category exists precisely because standard employment and unemployment figures miss people altogether: someone caring for a relative, someone whose training scheme folded, someone sending applications into silence can fall outside both columns. Jobcentres and monthly benefits are the visible machinery attached to the label, which is exactly why Morrison's imagined 10-year-old names them so precisely. The benefit claim is the part of Neet life that shows up in a spreadsheet. The rejection emails, the months of drift and the slow erosion of confidence do not.
The twist in her account is what happens after the obvious fix. Morrison now has work, and the precarity followed her through the door. That is the detail that should unsettle anyone who treats a job as the finish line of youth policy. It also matches what many people hiring and being hired at entry level already recognise: contracts that run short, hours that move, roles that exist quarter to quarter. Employment and security are not the same product, and a headline payroll number cannot tell you which one a worker actually has.
For the government, the political temptation is obvious. A plan that counts placements will look like a triumph within a year. A plan that counts how many of those people are still in stable work two or three years later will be judged far more harshly, and far more honestly. Morrison's request for long-term security is, in practice, a request to be measured on the second number. That reframes the entire exercise: the goal is not to move a young person off a benefit line, it is to move them onto a footing solid enough that they never go back to it.
There is a commercial case buried in the column, too. Employers that treat entry-level hiring as disposable pay for it later in churn, in training that walks out the door, and in a generation of workers who arrive with a rational suspicion of any promise made in an interview. Morrison's own credentials sharpen the point. She is a University of Glasgow graduate with a Gold Standard NCTJ Diploma, a qualification built for a trade that has itself been reshaped by insecure work. She is not describing a failure to prepare. She is describing a prepared person meeting an unprepared market.
What she offers is less a policy blueprint than a test. The government's plans to help young people outside education, work or training are welcome, she writes, and the word she adds is "dearly." The hope is sincere and the stakes are personal. The question now falls to ministers, boards and hiring managers alike: will the next cohort get work that lasts long enough to build a life on, or another version of the same uncertainty, this time with a payslip attached?
This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.
Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.
Register to UnlockAlways free for Executives Club members. Join the Club
More in Politics
Egypt's foreign minister: Hamas must hand over weapons for Gaza phase two
Badr Abdelatty tells Asharq Al-Awsat that Cairo is pressing Palestinian factions to implement weapons understandings, and that phase two of Trump's Gaza plan hinges on every party, Israel included, meeting its commitments.
Ministers lift gagging clauses at UK data watchdog ahead of culture probe
Staff at the Information Commission can now describe their workplace without contractual silence, and ministers are due to publish the review's terms next week.
Mahmood Tackles a 'Two-Tier Policing' Myth She Doesn't Believe Exists
The home secretary chose the path of least resistance on a claim a Guardian columnist calls a rightwing myth, while the Met's own record on the Stephen Port murders asks the harder question.



