Skip to content
LIVE
The Executives BriefThe Executives Brief

GTA 6 hits 99 on Metacritic, toppling Zelda as best-reviewed game ever

Rockstar's decade-in-the-making Vice City epic lands with an unprecedented 99/100, and every publisher with a release calendar now has a problem.

ByMaha Al-JuhaniEntertainment Correspondent, The Executives Brief
·3 min read
GTA 6 hits 99 on Metacritic, toppling Zelda as best-reviewed game ever
Executive summary

Rockstar Games' Grand Theft Auto VI launched to universal acclaim and an unprecedented 99/100 Metacritic score, vaulting above 1998's The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time as the best-reviewed game of all time. For publishers, platform holders and anyone planning a launch window, the bar for the next several years just moved.

Grand Theft Auto VI is out, and it has already done something no game has managed in the modern review era: it sits at the top of Metacritic's list of the best games of all time with a 99/100 score. That is not a rounding error or a niche category win. The title it displaced is 1998's The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, a game that has held the crown in most aggregations for an entire generation of players. The reviews landed mere hours into release, and the verdict, per The Guardian, was universal acclaim.

The timing explains the delirium. Gamers across Australia woke up Thursday morning feeling like Christmas had come early, some bleary-eyed from late-night sessions on the PlayStation, others already plotting a weekend foray into Vice City once their day jobs let them loose. Rockstar's Miami-inspired setting is the draw, but the systems are the hook: players can renovate houses, fix cars, lift weights and follow the story. Early coverage describes a "fully lived-in, breathable world", which is a polished way of saying the simulation runs deeper than the missions.

Why does a 99 matter more than a 97? Because review aggregation has a ceiling problem. Metacritic averages dozens of outlets, and a single dissenting critic drags the mean down. Scores in the high 90s are rare; a 99 is close to statistically unreachable, which is why Ocarina of Time's record survived roughly a quarter century of challengers. For context, the industry has spent that time getting bigger, more expensive and more risk-averse, and yet the top of the all-time list stayed frozen in 1998. GTA VI broke the freeze within hours.

The commercial architecture behind that score is worth understanding. Rockstar Games, owned by Take-Two Interactive, has been building this entry for more than a decade, per the report. That is an extraordinary bet in an industry where annualised franchises and live-service updates typically pay the bills. The prior entry, released in 2013, is widely cited as one of the biggest entertainment launches on record, and its online mode kept generating revenue long after the story ended. A decade-long development cycle only makes sense if the launch is treated as the beginning of a platform, not the end of a product. The 99 is the marketing engine for that tail.

Geography matters here too. Australia's Thursday morning wake-up is a timezone quirk that turns the country into an early read on a global launch, and the PlayStation is the platform named in the coverage. Console install bases, disc and digital splits, and regional pricing all shape how a launch like this converts acclaim into units. For platform holders, a system-selling exclusive-grade title is the single most valuable thing on the calendar, because it pulls hardware, subscriptions and storefront spend at once.

The second-order effects land on everyone else's schedule. When a title of this scale ships, rival publishers historically flinch: dates move, marketing budgets get reallocated, and smaller releases get buried under the news cycle. The deeper threat is structural. Features like renovating houses, fixing cars and lifting weights are retention mechanics dressed as flavour, the kind of systems that keep players inside one world for months rather than weeks. Every hour a player spends in Vice City is an hour not spent in a competitor's shooter, racing game or open-world adventure.

For decision-makers, the useful question is not whether GTA VI is good. It is what the 99 signals about where capital and attention are heading. Review scores function as a leading indicator for word of mouth, and word of mouth is what converts a launch window into a multi-year revenue curve. A record score also raises the cost of competing at the top: longer development cycles, bigger teams, higher marketing spend, and more pressure on studios to ship something that can survive the comparison. That is a hard bar for anyone without Rockstar's scale.

The strategic stakes for peers are straightforward. If you run a studio, your release calendar just got more crowded and your quality bar just got louder. If you run a platform, you want this title attached to your hardware and your subscription. If you allocate capital in media or gaming, the lesson is that patience at the top of the market can still be rewarded, even as the rest of the industry optimises for speed. Rockstar spent more than a decade on one bet. Hours into release, the reviews suggest it landed.

Executive ActionsLocked

This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.

Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.

Register to Unlock

Always free for Executives Club members. Join the Club

More in Entertainment