Skip to content
LIVE
The Executives BriefThe Executives Brief

NTNU study: your diet beats your food miles on climate impact

NTNU's Industrial Ecology Programme compared transport emissions against food production emissions, and the ranking upends where climate-conscious buyers, brands and supply chains should actually focus.

ByOmar Al-BalawiTechnology Correspondent, The Executives Brief
·4 min read
NTNU study: your diet beats your food miles on climate impact
Executive summary

Researchers at NTNU's Industrial Ecology Programme have published a study comparing greenhouse gas emissions from transportation with those from food production, concluding that what we eat matters more for the climate footprint than where it is grown. For food companies, retailers and investors, that finding shifts the emissions conversation from shipping distance to production method, which is exactly where Scope 3 disclosure and carbon labelling rules are heading.

A new study from NTNU's Industrial Ecology Programme lands a verdict that cuts against one of green consumerism's favourite ideas: what we eat matters more for the climate footprint than where it is grown. The Norwegian researchers set out to compare the proportion of greenhouse gas emissions that come from transportation with the emissions that come from producing the food itself. Transportation comes out behind. The farming, the land, the livestock, the fertilizer and the processing carry the bulk of the climate bill; moving the finished product from field to shelf carries a smaller slice.

That is a bigger deal than it sounds, because it reshuffles the mental model most shoppers and most supply chain teams are working from. For years the shorthand has been "food miles": the further your avocado or your tomato has travelled, the worse it is for the planet. The NTNU finding says that instinct is misfiring. The choice of what lands on the plate, not the distance it covered to get there, is where the leverage sits.

To understand why, it helps to know what the Industrial Ecology Programme at NTNU in Trondheim actually does. Industrial ecology is the discipline of tracking material and energy flows through an economy, essentially following stuff from extraction to disposal and putting a number on every stage. When a group like that turns its attention to food, it is not asking a philosophical question about eating local. It is building an emissions inventory and then asking which line items dominate.

The answer, in this case, is that the production side dominates. That is less strange than it first appears. Most food that crosses borders does so by ship, and bulk shipping is one of the most carbon-efficient ways humans have ever devised to move mass. A container vessel hauling grain or bananas across an ocean emits a small fraction per kilogram moved compared with a truck doing the last hundred miles, and a vanishing fraction compared with anything that flies. Air-freighted perishables are the glaring exception, but they are a thin slice of total food tonnage, typically reserved for high-value items like certain berries, asparagus and cut flowers.

Meanwhile, the production side is where the real emissions live. Clearing land for agriculture releases stored carbon. Cattle and sheep produce methane as part of digestion. Flooded rice paddies generate methane too. Nitrogen fertilizer manufacture and application release nitrous oxide, a potent greenhouse gas. On top of that, food systems as a whole are typically estimated to account for somewhere between a quarter and a third of global greenhouse gas emissions. Those are the numbers that move the needle, and they are set by what is grown and how, not by the length of the shipping route.

That is why the NTNU result matters well beyond academic debate. The shift from a distance-based metric to a production-based metric changes who looks good and who does not. A pasture-raised beef herd on the outskirts of your city, sold as a local, low-mileage product, can carry a far heavier climate footprint than lentils or chickpeas shipped in from another continent. Follow the logic and "local" stops being a reliable proxy for "low carbon." It is a proxy for short transport, which this study suggests is a smaller part of the puzzle than shoppers assume.

For anyone running a food business, that has direct commercial consequences. Corporate sustainability reporting regimes, including the EU's Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive, push large companies to account for Scope 3 emissions, which is where purchased agricultural inputs and ingredients sit. That means the production footprint of what a company buys is increasingly a disclosure line, not a marketing choice. Proposals like the EU's Green Claims Directive, aimed at stamping out vague or unsubstantiated environmental claims on packaging, raise the cost of leaning on "locally sourced" as an environmental selling point if the underlying product is emissions-heavy.

Retailers and consumer brands are already feeling the squeeze from a second direction: shoppers who want a simple signal. A carbon label that rewards short distances would, on this evidence, point consumers at the wrong products. A label built on production emissions would push traffic toward plant proteins, toward lower-methane agricultural practices and toward reformulating recipes. Those are supply chain and R&D decisions, not marketing decisions, and they carry multi-year lead times. Boards that wait for the labelling standard to settle before moving will end up renegotiating supplier contracts under deadline pressure.

The investor angle is straightforward. If the dominant emissions driver in food is production rather than transport, then the risk in a food portfolio sits with the agricultural base: livestock intensity, land-use change exposure, fertilizer dependence and the methane profile of the supply base. Those are the variables that will show up in transition plans and in the cost of capital long before a shipping lane does.

None of this means transport is irrelevant. Freight still burns fuel, aviation still carries a heavy per-kilogram penalty, and cold chain logistics are energy hungry. The point is proportion. The NTNU study's contribution is to put transport in its place relative to production, and in doing so to move the argument about sustainable food away from the geography of the supply chain and back to the composition of the plate. For operators, the practical question changes from "how far did this travel?" to "what is this made of, and how was it produced?" That is a harder question to answer, which is exactly why it is worth asking first.

Executive ActionsLocked

This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.

Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.

Register to Unlock

Always free for Executives Club members. Join the Club

More in Science