Psychopathy and sadism boost second-date odds, and first impressions explain it
A new study finds the traits daters say they least want are the ones that get them asked back out, a warning for anyone who trusts a first meeting.

A new study reported by Phys.org finds that dark personality traits, specifically psychopathy and sadism, are linked to a better chance of getting a second date even though few people say they want those traits in a partner. For executives, the finding is a reminder that short, high-pressure interactions, from first dates to first interviews to first pitches, reward performance over substance and should not carry the weight of a final decision.
The traits people say they want least in a partner are the ones that appear to get them asked out again. A new study reported by Phys.org finds that dark personality traits, specifically psychopathy and sadism, are linked to a better chance of landing a second date. That is not because daters are secretly shopping for a manipulator. It is because the qualities that make someone a bad long-term bet do not necessarily register as a warning in the first hour. Psychopathy, as the research frames it, involves manipulation, low empathy and impulsivity. Sadism involves taking pleasure in other people's suffering. Very few people say they want either. Yet on a first date, those traits do not stop someone from coming across as an appealing romantic partner.
That is the tension in a single sentence: what people say they want and who they actually ask out again point in different directions. Ask anyone what they are looking for and you get kindness, stability, humor, someone who replies to a text. Watch who gets the second date and the picture gets murkier. The finding is not that dark traits are attractive on their own. It is that they are not disqualifying at the moment of first impression, which is a stranger and more useful claim. A first date is a short, high-pressure, low-information interaction. It rewards confidence, quick wit, steady eye contact, a willingness to take social risks and the ability to stay unbothered when the conversation turns awkward. Those are surface behaviors, and surface behaviors are exactly what a single meeting can measure.
For context, psychopathy and sadism are two of the traits psychologists have long grouped under the so-called Dark Triad and, in later work, the Dark Tetrad. The classic trio is psychopathy, narcissism and Machiavellianism; sadism is the fourth that researchers typically add. These traits have historically been studied in workplaces, in negotiations and in leadership, where the same pattern tends to show up: people who score high on them often do well in short, competitive, impression-driven settings and poorly in long, cooperative ones. That is the background that makes the dating result less surprising than it first sounds. The study is not claiming that cruelty is a mating strategy. It is documenting a gap between what a brief encounter can detect and what a relationship eventually requires.
The mechanism is not mysterious. First impressions are a low-resolution instrument. They capture warmth, status, confidence and social ease, all of which can be performed. They cannot capture how someone behaves when they are bored, contradicted, inconvenienced or asked to compromise. A first date is essentially a structured interview with no reference checks. The candidate controls the narrative, the stakes are low, and the interviewer is distracted by their own nerves. Under those conditions, the person who is calmest and most fluent has an edge, regardless of what is underneath the calm.
The parallel to business is close enough to be uncomfortable. Founders pick co-founders, boards pick CEOs, investors pick founders and hiring managers pick candidates, all on the strength of a handful of high-pressure conversations. The same asymmetry applies. The person who interviews best is not always the person who performs best, and the traits that make someone magnetic in a room are not the traits that make them reliable over a decade. Anyone who has watched a charismatic hire flame out, or a smooth pitch deck meet a messy cap table, has already met this study in another form.
It is worth being precise about what the finding does and does not say. It links dark traits to a better chance at a second date. It does not say those dates go well, that the relationships last, or that anyone should seek those partners out. The gap it exposes is about selection, not satisfaction. The first date is a filter, and filters are only as good as the signals they can read. A filter tuned to charm will select for charm. Whether charm correlates with the things you actually care about is a separate question, and usually the answer is: not as much as you would hope.
The practical response is not cynicism. It is structure. If short interactions reward performance, then decisions that matter should not rest on short interactions alone. Add touchpoints. Ask for evidence rather than impressions. Talk to people who have seen the candidate, the founder or the partner under pressure and over time. Delay the verdict past the point where the performance gets expensive to maintain. None of this is a guarantee, but it shifts the odds away from whoever is simply best at the first hour.
The uncomfortable takeaway is that the first date is a performance test, not a values test, and most of us grade it as if it were the latter. The study's contribution is to put a dent in the assumption that people can spot a bad partner early. They cannot, at least not reliably, and the traits that should send them running are sometimes the ones that get them to lean in. That is worth remembering the next time someone makes an extraordinary first impression, whether across a dinner table or a boardroom table. Charm is a signal. It is just not the signal most people think it is.
This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.
Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.
Register to UnlockAlways free for Executives Club members. Join the Club
More in Science
Anthropic's I.P.O. Made Rank-and-File Researchers Worth Tens of Millions
Researchers who joined just a few years ago are now worth tens of millions, and the windfall resets the pay benchmark for every private A.I. lab still paying in paper.
Sea Lion Culling Strategy Fails: New Model Says Killing Them Won't Save Salmon
The latest research from AAAS overturn a long-held conservation assumption, forcing policymakers to rethink critical resource allocation in marine ecosystems.
Microplastics do more than pile up: they react with water to damage cells
Scientists have found that plastic particles can generate highly reactive molecules in water, a mechanism that could explain links to heart attacks, strokes, and neurological disorders.


