Skip to content
LIVE
The Executives BriefThe Executives Brief

Shepard's voice actor wants EA to sell Mass Effect to its fans

Jennifer Hale's plan: a Critical Role-style Kickstarter, a governed fan collective, and a fair price for EA, which she argues cannot buy that kind of goodwill.

ByMaha Al-JuhaniEntertainment Correspondent, The Executives Brief
·4 min read
Shepard's voice actor wants EA to sell Mass Effect to its fans
Executive summary

Jennifer Hale, the actor who voiced Commander Shepard, is urging EA to sell the Mass Effect IP to a fan-run collective funded by a Critical Role-style Kickstarter, after BioWare's shutdown left the franchise's future uncertain. For decision-makers, the pitch reframes dormant intellectual property as a reputational asset and tests whether goodwill can actually be priced into a sale.

Jennifer Hale, the actor who voiced Commander Shepard across the Mass Effect trilogy, wants EA to sell the franchise to its fans. With BioWare shut down and the future of the sci-fi RPG series deeply uncertain, Hale is backing the fandom's Save Mass Effect movement and pitching something far bigger: a Critical Role-style Kickstarter that would buy the IP outright and place it in community hands. Her first reaction to the idea, she tells GamesRadar+, was blunt. 'The first phrase, honestly, that comes to my mind is money on the table, baby.'

Hale's ties to BioWare run well before EA acquired the studio in 2007. 'I initially felt sad when BioWare was sold to EA because there was a spirit at BioWare that I believe endured for quite a long time, all the way till the theoretical closure,' she says. 'But I missed the maverick. I missed the brave solo indie company that just kicked ass. Forgive my French.' She calls EA's own acquisition by a Saudi-led investment group a 'further dagger to the heart,' one she expects to usher in an era of what she calls 'shareholder supremacy.' And yet, when BioWare was actually shut down, Hale says she 'got really excited and hopeful.' She had a vision.

That vision is a 'Mass Effect collective,' a fan-governed body that would hold the IP. 'I just have this vision of all these fans coming together, [and] making a glorious Kickstarter, just like the folks at Critical Role did,' she explains. 'Games are expensive, so maybe one or two well-heeled individuals who enjoy investing in creative ventures come along and fortify that. Then an indie game company, or any game company with openness and vision that's story-driven and community-conscious, comes into the picture to make it so.' The collective would run on governing rules and stay open to the community, split into two categories: non-monetized and monetized. In the monetized lane, Hale suggests 'maybe a tiny portion of everything everybody makes goes into a fund that helps displaced devs. Wouldn't that be nice, to have something like that?'

The harder sell is to EA itself. Former developers have noted that 'EA never actually sells anything,' and the publisher carries billions in debt to pay off. Hale thinks Mass Effect is the rare case where selling makes sense. 'I think it would be incredibly smart on EA's part to settle on a reasonable, fair price for the IP that respects the fact that it's not a wealthy corporation buying it. It's a collective,' she says. Then comes the goodwill argument, delivered with an MBA's vocabulary. 'You know, EA, you can't buy that kind of publicity. You cannot buy that kind of goodwill. The love that people and appreciation people would have for you for a long time, and the hats off to you would be invaluable. I have a business degree, and there is such a thing on the books called goodwill, and it is invaluable.'

The counterargument writes itself. If goodwill were that valuable to EA, BioWare would presumably still be alive and making Mass Effect 5. A balance sheet carrying billions in debt, not a reputation ledger, governs decisions at that scale, and handing a marquee IP to a fan collective would set a precedent no publisher wants to set for its other franchises. Hale's proposal also raises governance questions: who sits on the collective, how disputes get resolved, who owns derivative works, and what happens when the crowdfunding runs dry and the next game still costs far more than any campaign typically raises.

Still, the mechanics are not fantasy. Critical Role proved a passionate audience will fund a production company at scale, and crowdfunding has bankrolled sequels to cult franchises after publishers walked away. What is new is the ask: not a license or a spinoff, but ownership of the underlying IP, held by a governed collective with revenue-sharing rules baked in. That looks less like a fan campaign and more like a cooperative, arriving as gaming's biggest assets consolidate into fewer, larger hands. For context, state-linked funds have spent years buying into interactive entertainment, and the friction between long-horizon owners and impatient communities is only sharpening.

For executives watching, the interesting question is not whether EA says yes. It is the valuation problem Hale forces into the open. What is a dormant IP worth to a company that may never make another game with it, versus what is it worth to the people who will? Goodwill, as she notes, is a real line item, and community sentiment now feeds directly into franchise value, launch risk, and talent recruitment. A publisher that sells to a collective at a fair price books a modest gain and a durable reputational asset. A publisher that sits on the IP books nothing, and watches the fandom's energy migrate to whatever fills the vacuum.

Hale is not pretending the odds are good. 'Who knows? This could happen. I'm all on board for whatever,' she says. 'There is so much possibility in this universe. It's vast. You could have stories with multiverses. I always joke, like, Where's Mass Effect: The Musical? Because I started as a singer. I started singing in clubs, rock clubs, when I was like 15. I'm like, Bring me the musical!' It is a long shot with a real number attached, and that is the point. The pitch is on the table, and EA now has to decide what its silence is worth.

Executive ActionsLocked

This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.

Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.

Register to Unlock

Always free for Executives Club members. Join the Club

More in Entertainment