Tarantino and Fincher's Cliff Booth Debuts at 84% Before Netflix Christmas
First reviews hand the Once Upon a Time... in Hollywood spinoff an 84% score, call it Fincher's best since Gone Girl, and set up an IMAX warm-up for a Christmas Netflix launch.

Quentin Tarantino wrote and David Fincher directed The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth, starring Brad Pitt, and first reviews put it at 84% on Rotten Tomatoes ahead of an IMAX run next week and a Netflix release this Christmas. For media executives, the film is a test case in pairing auteur brands with a star-driven spinoff, using a theatrical window to feed an awards campaign and a holiday streaming debut.
The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth lands with an 84% score on Rotten Tomatoes from its first reviews, and that number is doing real work for Netflix. Quentin Tarantino wrote the script, David Fincher directed it, and Brad Pitt returns as the stuntman he played in Once Upon a Time... in Hollywood. The film hits IMAX screens next week before arriving on Netflix this Christmas, the theatrical-then-streaming sequence the streamer has made its signature move for prestige titles. The cast includes Elizabeth Debicki, Scott Caan, and Yahya Abdul-Mateen II.
Critics are not treating this as a curiosity. Alfred Castaneda of Shade Studios wrote that "Fincher ends his Netflix run with his most fun film since Fight Club and his best movie since Gone Girl." Chris Evangelista of Slashfilm agreed: "Fincher's best movie in years - since Gone Girl, really." Matt Oakes of Silver Screen Riot added that "his direction hasn't been this sharp and laser-focused in years." That is a striking verdict for a director whose Netflix run is now closing, and it reframes the project from spinoff exercise into something closer to a career statement.
The pairing itself is the draw, and reviewers split on whether the two styles fuse or collide. David Gonzalez of The Cinematic Reel wrote that "it's safe to say that David Fincher and Quentin Tarantino make beautiful music together," while Don Shanahan of Every Movie Has a Lesson called the synthesis "a cinephile's dream come true." David Rooney of The Hollywood Reporter framed the split appeal: "Tarantino disciples will eat it up, while Fincher obsessives should find plenty of the director's pungent atmospherics, his technical flair and moody visual style." Owen Gleiberman of Variety said the two "merge in a divertingly odd way." Mike Ryan of The Hard Pass described the effect precisely: the scenes read as "loose and flowing, like a Tarantino script would. But they also feel unusually tense." Not everyone bought it. David Ehrlich of IndieWire argued the film "ultimately dilutes them both instead of sparking some kind of unexpected kismet between them."
Pitt is the constant. David Gonzalez called it "his best performance since Once Upon a Time... in Hollywood." Matt Oakes went further: "As good as he was in Once Upon a Time, he's even better here, because this time he has more to do." Alfred Castaneda said flatly that "Pitt's better here than he was in Once Upon A Time... in Hollywood." David Ehrlich described "the drawling magic of Pitt's performance, which he continues to wear like a second skin." Liz Shannon Miller of Consequence landed the best line: "Watching Brad Pitt be cool on screen is like watching a jellyfish float in the sea - if there's effort involved, it isn't obvious." Giovanni Lago of Next Best Picture noted Pitt "hasn't been this alive on screen since Babylon."
The supporting cast is generating its own awards chatter. Miller said Elizabeth Debicki "proves more than capable of going toe-to-toe with Pitt." Gonzalez called her "the true MVP," adding she "was born to deliver Tarantino dialogue." Castaneda wrote he could see her "in the running for Best Supporting Actress this year." Lago praised Scott Caan, who "delivers his best performance," and Rooney said Caan is "doing some of his best work," with Gugino also bringing "her A-game." Ehrlich singled out Peter Weller as Gus Booth, "winsome and wonderful."
The knock is that there is not much plot to knock. Gleiberman admitted he "dug just about every ambling, low-down minute of this one," and Joey Magidson of Awards Radar said the film "is exactly what it's advertising. Did you enjoy hanging out with Brad Pitt's stuntman character? If so, you're in luck." Rooney predicted "few fans will complain." But William Bibbiani of TheWrap wrote that "by the time the credits roll, it's clear this story didn't mean anything to Cliff Booth, and by extension, much of anything at all." Gleiberman described the mood as "disarmingly placid," as if "someone had slipped the movie half a Quaalude." Lisa Laman of The Spool called it "largely disposable," and Evangelista wished "Tarantino had just gone ahead and directed this himself."
Fincher supplied the sharpest description himself, calling it "Shampoo with violence," which Gleiberman called "an ace description." Bibbiani found "a lot of Robert Altman's neo-noir The Long Goodbye in here, and even more of Brian Trenchard-Smith's Stunt Rock," while Rooney detected "an Elmore Leonard kinship in the crime elements." For newcomers, Abe Friedtanzer of Awards Buzz suggested someone who has not seen the predecessor "might not actually be missing much," though Lex Amoriello of Movie Recs by Lex noted the film "is filled with references to its predecessor" even as it stands on its own.
The commercial logic is straightforward. Netflix gets a star-driven, auteur-branded title with an IMAX showcase and a Christmas date timed for awards consideration. Fincher gets a theatrical-grade close to his Netflix run. Tarantino extends his most commercially friendly universe without sitting in the director's chair. The open question is whether a hangout movie with a thin plot converts viewers who never saw the 2019 original, and whether the same looseness that some critics call disposable is exactly what made Cliff Booth a fan favorite in the first place. For studios weighing similar spinoffs, the lesson is that the IP matters less than the pairing: a writer with a voice, a director with a system, and a movie star who makes it look effortless.
This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.
Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.
Register to UnlockAlways free for Executives Club members. Join the Club
More in Entertainment
GTA 6 banks $3.8bn in one day, torching every launch record
One game just out-earned every video game launch and every single-day film box office haul in history, and the fallout lands on every media CEO's forecast.
GTA VI Racked Up $3.79 Billion in a Single Day, Topping Every Film Ever
A 13-year wait produced a $3.79 billion day, more than any movie has made in its entire run, and it resets the launch math for every studio, streamer, and brand chasing the same attention.
GTA 6 sells 32.5M pre-sales and $3.79B day one, torches 13-year record
Rockstar's sequel didn't just beat Grand Theft Auto V's 13-year-old benchmark; it reset what a launch can be, with 32.5 million pre-sale copies and $3.79 billion in a single day.


