Skip to content
LIVE
The Executives BriefThe Executives Brief

The networking paradox: your best-connected colleague is the least trusted

Research reported by Phys.org finds the people best positioned to make introductions are the ones peers hesitate to vouch for, which reshapes how you pick boards, deal teams, and successors.

ByReem Al-DosariMarkets Editor, The Executives Brief
·3 min read
The networking paradox: your best-connected colleague is the least trusted
Executive summary

Research reported by Phys.org finds a networking paradox: the professionals best positioned to connect others, the brokers who span departments and companies, are also the ones others are least inclined to trust. For executives, that means reach and reliability are separate assets, and the person you tap to run introductions may need a different kind of proof before peers will actually follow them.

In the business world, knowing the right people is treated as a passport to success. A well-connected professional can introduce colleagues to new clients, pull experts out of different departments, and create collaborations that would never otherwise happen. The catch, according to research reported by Phys.org: the people best positioned to connect others may also be the ones others are least inclined to trust. Reach and trust, in other words, are not the same asset. They can pull against each other.

That is the networking paradox, and it is uncomfortable because it cuts against nearly every instinct in hiring, promotion, and dealmaking. We reward the person who knows everyone. We put them on the panel, hand them the warm intro, send them to the conference with the company badge. The finding says the same profile that makes someone a superb connector is the profile that makes peers hesitate when it counts: when they have to vouch, refer, or hand over something that cannot be taken back.

For context on why the structure matters, network research has long distinguished between two kinds of value in a contact list. There is density, meaning how tightly a group already knows each other, and there is the brokerage position, meaning the person who sits in the gap between groups that do not talk. Brokers typically see deals, talent, and information before anyone else, because they are the only route across. That position is genuinely valuable. It is also, structurally, a position of asymmetry: the broker knows what flows in both directions, and the people on either side do not. Historically, that asymmetry is exactly what makes a middleman useful, and exactly what makes people wonder what the middleman is doing with the view.

Trust, by contrast, is built on something narrower: repeated, verifiable behavior inside a group that can compare notes. Your five closest collaborators can check each other. They see whether you show up, whether you keep a confidence, whether your introductions turn out well. A broker's network is too wide for that kind of mutual verification. The people on one side of the gap cannot audit what the broker does on the other side. So the very breadth that generates opportunity also removes the social accounting that generates trust.

The second-order effects land in places executives do not usually look. Consider the board seat. A director with an enormous network is a magnet for introductions, but if peers are slow to trust that director's judgment, the introductions may not convert into anything. Consider the deal team. The rainmaker who knows every founder in a sector may be the wrong person to run diligence, because diligence is a trust exercise: you need people to tell you the unflattering thing, early and unprompted. Consider succession. The obvious heir is often the most connected person in the room, and the finding suggests that is a reason to look harder, not a reason to stop looking.

There is also a personal cost that ambitious readers should price in. If you are the connector, you are accumulating a specific kind of suspicion alongside your specific kind of advantage. The counter is not to shrink your network. It is to make the invisible visible: close loops publicly, say who you introduced and why, let outcomes be checked, and keep a smaller inner ring where you are accountable in the ordinary way. Reach without a track record reads as leverage. Reach with a track record reads as leadership.

For anyone building a career or a company, the practical read is that network size is a vanity metric and network shape is the real one. Ask not how many people you know but where you sit relative to them, and whether the people who matter can verify what you do when they are not watching. The paradox does not say stop networking. It says the passport and the visa are different documents, and you need both.

Executive ActionsLocked

This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.

Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.

Register to Unlock

Always free for Executives Club members. Join the Club

More in Science