Skip to content
LIVE
The Executives BriefThe Executives Brief

UCT: nature-based climate fixes fail informal settlements without power-sharing

New University of Cape Town research argues consultation is not enough, and that adaptation funders and city governments must hand real decision rights to the residents living with the risk.

ByNora Al-SubaieSenior Correspondent, The Executives Brief
·3 min read
UCT: nature-based climate fixes fail informal settlements without power-sharing
Executive summary

New research from the University of Cape Town concludes that nature-based solutions for climate adaptation are failing informal settlements because they stop at participation instead of power-sharing. For funders, mayors and planners, the consequence is a rewrite of how adaptation projects are designed, funded and measured, with decision rights and land tenure treated as preconditions rather than afterthoughts.

New research out of the University of Cape Town (UCT) lands a blunt verdict on one of the fastest-growing tools in climate adaptation: nature-based solutions are failing informal settlements, and the problem is not the science. It is the politics. The finding argues that projects built on restoring mangroves, wetlands, urban trees and riverbanks will keep missing the people they are meant to protect as long as they stop at participation, meaning consultation, workshops and stakeholder meetings, instead of moving to power-sharing partnerships.

That is a direct challenge to how adaptation money is typically spent. Participation has been the default standard in development practice for decades: bring residents into the room, gather their input, then design and build. The UCT research says that model is structurally insufficient. What informal settlements bring is not just feedback but lived experience and existing relationships with nature, and those are treated as data to be collected rather than authority to be shared. The distinction sounds academic. It is not. It decides who sits at the table when a project is scoped, who signs off on siting, and who is still standing there when the water comes back.

Informal settlements are, historically, where climate risk concentrates hardest. They are typically self-built, often on land nobody else wanted: floodplains, steep slopes, the edges of landfills, drainage corridors. Residents frequently lack formal tenure, which quietly determines who gets a seat at the planning table and who gets relocated when a project breaks ground. That combination, high exposure plus weak formal standing, is exactly why adaptation projects land there first and why they so often disappoint. The people with the most to lose have the least say over the intervention designed to save them.

For context, nature-based solutions cover a wide family of interventions: restoring mangroves and wetlands to absorb storm surge, planting urban canopy to cut heat, reopening culverted rivers to manage flooding. Multilateral climate funds, development banks, city governments and a growing pool of private capital have backed them because they can be cheaper than concrete and steel and because they stack benefits: cooling, drainage, biodiversity, amenity. The catch, as the UCT work frames it, is that those benefits accrue to whoever holds decision rights over the land.

Power-sharing, in this framing, is not a warmer version of consultation. It means residents and their organizations hold real authority over design, siting, maintenance and the rules of access, and that their relationship with a river, a wetland or a hillside is treated as expertise rather than sentiment. That has operational consequences. Budgets have to fund community institutions, not just contractors. Timelines have to survive local politics. Monitoring has to measure who decided, not how many attended.

The second-order effects are where this gets uncomfortable for funders. If power-sharing becomes the standard, projects that cannot demonstrate shared authority face reputational and, increasingly, political risk. Cities that green a floodplain without settling tenure can trigger the displacement dynamic practitioners commonly call green gentrification: improvements raise land values, and the residents who needed the protection are priced out of it. Insurers and municipal finance officers, meanwhile, inherit the liability when a project that looked good in a proposal fails in a storm.

None of this is easy, and the research does not pretend otherwise. Devolving authority is slower, messier and harder to report upward to funders who want clean metrics. Community organizations are not monolithic; giving one group power can sideline another. But the alternative, the UCT argument runs, is a portfolio of well-intentioned green infrastructure that keeps producing the same outcome: adaptation that arrives, and protection that does not.

For the people who sign off on adaptation spending, the practical question is what changes Monday morning. Three things. First, treat tenure and decision rights as preconditions, not side issues. Second, rewrite success metrics so they capture authority transferred, not workshops held. Third, expect the communities with the deepest exposure to be the ones with the sharpest read on what actually works, because they have been living with the water for years. The research from UCT is a warning shot: nature-based solutions are only as resilient as the partnerships underneath them.

Executive ActionsLocked

This story's Key Insights and Take-aways are locked.

Create a free account to unlock Executive Actions for one credit.

Register to Unlock

Always free for Executives Club members. Join the Club

More in Science